M
Is there a legal or similar reason why a copy of the text cannot be included in the PDF file for media lessons?
I like the alternate male and female voices. Am I right that the last part was not read by Vera?
V
We don't have the copy right of the text so we can't have it in the pdf. I didn't read the text.
M
But the text is on a web site that can be copied. I have done so and have saved the text in a file so I can study it at will. I just wondered why you don't do the same and supply it in the pdf.
F
If you use a mac it's relatively easy to add text to the course PDF. Paste text into a WP app and save as PDF. Open the new PDF doc and the CP course PDF in Preview, the default PDF reader for OS X. Toggle the view menu in the upper-left corner of the doc and select thumbnails. Drag and drop pages to combine in one doc.
I find it more convenient to study from PDF docs offline. I use this method to combine expansion and grammar docs with the course PDF.
M
Thank you. That is interesting. I don't use a Mac but I will see if there is some equivalent way with Microsoft. I wonder why Chinesepod doesn't do it though to save us the trouble.
If they did, that would get over the problem that the link gets out of date.
Y
Request you to share the website url where the text can be picked up from?
Thanks in advance.
M
http://baby.163.com/14/0423/08/9QGJR7E800364MNT.html
Actually Chinesepod give the link to it at the top of this page in red characters.
S
Even though the article is on a website that can be copied, it is still protected by digital copyright laws. Just because it 'can' be copied doesn't mean that it is legal to do so! Whether one makes money from it is irrelevant to copyright laws; they simply determine who has the rights to reproduce the work and under what circumstances. Individuals get away with it with relative impunity (usually), but a commercial site is unlikely to be able to do so.
M
Thanks - I guess that is what I suspected.
I can't quite get my head around copyright applied to the internet though, as just anybody can access the page and the information is 'copied' onto their screens... Does that mean that printing an internet page is illegal?
R
Even Judges are having trouble getting their heads around copyright and the internet. Here are two articles that at least explain the problem if not the solution. Cpod is right to be careful.
http://www.pitt.edu/~skvarka/education/copyright/
http://blog.kissmetrics.com/break-the-law-marketing/
M
An (admittedly cursory) look at the these links still makes me a unsure as to whether a news item placed specifically for public consumption, like a news item, by the author can be deemed to be available ... That is why I wondered if Chinesepod might like to answer the question from their point of view.
S
In the States, the issue is 'fair use', which is vaguely and contextually defined (necessarily so). The issues are complex, but what you are asking for (republishing the whole article verbatim) would clearly be illegal, since the article is not explicitly 'public domain'. However, if CPod were to modify the article considerably, editing and inserting large amounts of commentary essential for their teaching purposes, they would probably have a good case for fair use.
Regarding the issue of printing: it is legal to print a copy of a newspaper article if it is for personal use.
(By the way, I am not a lawyer, but an educator who regularly attends copyright workshops on campus for professional reasons.) Hopefully, CPod will be gracious enough to explain to you if the same criteria apply in China.



