Main Site Blog Help

Lesson 1826: 孔子拜访老子 1:道可道非常道

Discussion of the lesson 孔子拜访老子 1:道可道非常道.

Comments left on the lesson page appear here, and replies posted here appear under the lesson.

13
created: C Dec '11 last reply: W Jun '14 28 replies 0 views 12 users 0 likes 0 links

Frequent Posters

8
5
4
3
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
There are 28 replies with an estimated read time of 4 minutes.
This sounds intruiging; pity I won't be able to listen to it until later! (Christmas is keeping me busy!) Glad to have Chinese Pod back up after maintenance!
3
oh yeah, great topic. Can't wait to listen in on their convo. Wonder who will be the actors? Surely XuZhou will have to be one. Gotta have someone wise sounding enough to play the part, hehe.
3
Ha ha - this sounds like me and my teacher reading the 三字经 - we read a bit then he asks 'what do you think that means?' I tell him, and he says 不对!  So far I have read and understood seventy four 4-line stanzas, but I cannot articulate them apparently. Am I wrong in trying? I have written up fifteen of them in a blog. Yes, I know that there are hundreds of English translations but the couple I have looked at don't give me SATISFACTION!.  
3
Can we go check out your blog?! Where?
3
This book presents many of Kongzi's sayings in the original Chinese, then 'translates' them into modern day Chinese, then gives a substantial explanation of each, also in modern Chinese: 论语选评 (ISBN: 7-80665-742-8).
3
Guolan - thanks for that reference.
3
If you would like to send me an IM and email address I will give you a reference.
3
"we read a bit then he asks 'what do you think that means?' I tell him, and he says 不对!" Ha Ha - I love that! Keep going bozi! As they say (or maybe they don't???) 过程比结果重要。 I'd love to check out your blog too and get a little taster of the 三字经. How can we IM you? Is that something we can do through the chinesepod site?  
3
'Keep going bozi!' That is very funny - the sort of joke my teacher would not appreciate. :) As they say (or maybe they don't???) 过程比结果重要。I can't recall any Chinese person saying this but it is food for thought, and I am wondering if somewhere in the 三字经 this will be expressed. I will make this available shortly but I need to advise that (1) my commentary is far from finished!, (2) it is in English, and (3) it is written to 'an imaginary and clever little ten year old.' It does not look anything like a 'serious'/published translation. At one stage I comment on how the interpretation of these texts change over time. It is public property, so different families interpret it in different ways, depending on their personal philosophy, or depending on their local culture. (Consider how a minority group may view it compared to the 汉族... ) A small quote (slightly modified to fit our conversation): '... Last stanza I softened the 三字经 message somewhat – the three ‘standards of behaviour’ actually convey the idea that the king sets the rules for the subject, the father for the son, and the husband for the wife. There is no shame in modifying the scriptures of previous generations – it is an old respected tradition. … :D The stanza's original meaning is more along the lines: 君为臣纲 (the king, for the subject, sets the rules, 义 trust each other) 父为子纲 (the father, for the son, sets the rules, 亲 be intimate and close) 夫为妇纲 (the husband, for the wife, sets the rules, 顺 travel in the same direction)... By IM I means a personal message on this site, yes.
3
哈哈,我很喜欢这个“道可道,非常道”。。。我每天整天打算用这个说法,不用说别的。。。希望会让我看起来非常明智,呵呵
3
两个演员和对话都非常好!我一定不是失望了
3
我不能得到任何的!
3
哈哈,“柏子”。。我很喜欢。。以后我要继续称柏子“柏子”
3
我可不可以建议柏子新的头像?:
3
可以阿。是不是柏树的种子?阴和阳? 是芝麻街性格演员吧?
3
"可以阿" 。。噢,呵呵,多谢柏子朋友 “是柏树的子” 。。就是 “阴和阳” 。。哈哈,再说就是。你真聪明! “是芝麻街性格演员吧? ” 不是,我是创始人,哈哈
3
柏子先生,久仰大卫!
3
0:12 内容呢,是去听一下 0:30 对中国人甚至整个世界 1:34 可以教他孔zhouni 16:04 非常的chao超 9: 53 环游世界的梦想 10:21 比较qiong送不起的 14:22 养神 14:31 我们是系上了 14: 40 qingqingwuwei 15:39 理智,德zhi,renzhi 谢谢!
3
0:12 内容呢,是去听一下 0:30 对中国人甚至整个世界 1:34 可以叫他孔仲尼。 16:04 非常的潮 9: 53 环游世界的梦想 10:21 比较穷,送不起吧 14:22 养生 14:31 我们是继承了 14: 40 清静无为 15:39 礼治,德治,仁治
3
谢谢!
3
一些词语: 清静          qīng jìng             beautiful weather; peace and quiet 无为          wú wéi                inaction; let things take their own course 表述          biǎo shù             express; enunciate; formulate 继承          jì chéng              to inherit; to carry on; to succeed 敬仰          jìng yǎng            to revere; to esteem; to adore 仰慕          yǎng mù             to admire; to respect 偏差          piān chā             bias; deviation; [Physics] declination 付諸实施    fù zhū shí shī      carry out; put into effect 庄子         Zhuāng Zi            Zhuang Zi 李耳           Li Ěr                    Lao Zi 孔仲尼      Kǒng Zhòng Ní    Confucious 環遊世界   huán yóu shì jiè   to travel round the world 參透        cān tòu                 perception; insight into a profound thought
3
孔子讲话为何那么有气无力?
3
上了这堂课,我感觉:道可道,非常道,不知道。
3
“道可道,非常道”是一个固定的说法吧。我估计信道的人常常说这个来表达道学的深奥,老百姓则用这个说法讽笑他们。
3
没有信道教的老百姓吗?其实这是真正的问题;现代中国文化里道教有什么地位?
3
我的学校没有强调任何宗教,而且菲律宾的华侨大部份是做生意的。所以我对道教不太认识。我想台湾应该有道教的信徒。
3
有趣的是,这句话原来是"道可道非恒道",只是老子去世几百年后,为了避讳汉文帝刘恒的名字,才改"恒"为"常"。所以如果说"道可道非常道"而不是"恒道"就不知不觉中等于向世俗妥协,向权势屈服,好像跟道家的思想有些出入,但这样窜改已经根深蒂固。 诶,真神奇,对话里的老子居然能预料到几百年后会有一个帝王叫刘恒,而为了尊敬他改了自己原来的话,真可谓神机妙算而又卑躬屈膝。;)
3
这么老的人如何说《B和A》呢?《甲和乙》在这种北京最合适!太让那个古老的精神被破坏了!
3
Leave a reply

Posting as a guest. Your reply is reviewed before it appears. Log in to post without review.