mark
Jun '10
看我们的行为,人肯定是一种猴子。:=) 很好又一次听到“Saved by the Gong"的队。
3
Tal
Jun '10
非常有意思的课文啊!而且课文的图片很典型表现进化论。我只好跟mark同意,我觉得我们基本上还是古猿!
3
changye
Jun '10
人类起源地为什么只有一个?这是不是说明非洲的猴子当时最聪明?
3
JasonSch
Jun '10
好像是跟环境和气候有关系吧。不过说实话我也不太确定!
3
Tal
Jun '10
其实,古老的时候有各种各样的阶段的人类,各种各样的《猿人》。我们自己的种是只有一个继续存在。不过,这些各种各样的《猿人》都在非洲起源。
3
tanglang
Jun '10
当然是坏事。如果我们人真的从猴子进化过来的, 在非洲有猴子变成"人", 在北京有另外一个变成"人", 结果我们到头来并不是一个人类而是许多不同的高级猴子, 并不平等。
3
changye
Jun '10
正面是宗教不干扰学校科学教育,负面是在中国宗教自由受很大限制。
3
henning
Jun '10
I found the following expression from the dialogue interesting:
后肢独立承担起了行走的责任
The legs "took responsibility for the task"? So 承担责任can be used for things without a free will? Maybe the translation "take responsibility" doesn't cover the full spectrum of 承担责任 and it is here more a general "took over the task of"?
3
Tal
Jun '10
难道你不是完全进化论懂的?现在在非洲肯定没有一种猴子变成人了,而很久很久以前有《古猿》,其实各种各样的古猿。这些古猿是现代猿与现代人类的祖先。说起《北京猿人》,这种猿人也是原来从非洲来的。
3
bababardwan
Jun '10
hahadaxiao...great pic tal and perfectly displayed..got this html nailed to boot
3
Tal
Jun '10
Cheers mate, I just used the 'insert an image' link for it though!
3
bababardwan
Jun '10
doh,because I was on subthread and your inserted photo was lined up perfectly with that forgot you weren't. I've found it hard to get the size right in subthread insertion of photos previously. Still a great pic.
3
tanglang
Jun '10
你评论好像自己当时在场。我其实一点不懂进化论,因为它的根据是假设而并非事实。如果《北京猿人》来自非洲, 那么《香港猿人》, 《新加坡猿人》, 《丝绸之路猿人》等在那里?。估计猿人没有座过飞机到北京。如果他真的从非洲过来, 问题还在: 我们人不是一个人类大家庭,因为这样的话今天的东亚人很可能是《北京猿人》, 西方人是另外一个猿人的后代, 结果没有设么平等可言。
3
tanglang
Jun '10
sensitive subject, very balanced lesson. Funny & educative!
3
tanglang
Jun '10
take a close look to the avatar of tal_. His finger points in the right direction :)
3
xiaophil
Jun '10
CPod
你们别介意,可是你的上面的介绍不对。接下来是你们写的:
“一个连聪明的科学家们都无法解决的问题——人是从哪儿来的?”
你们写的“无法解决”有误导性,意味着科学家绞尽脑汁,可是不能做出结论。其实事实就是这样,绝大多数进化的专家都同意人类和现代的猴子有一个共同的祖先。虽然这些科学家还没完全解决每个小细节,不过全面趋势很明确——现代的人类就是一种进化过程的产物。因此,你们CPod人员说“无法解决”十分不合适。你们应该写:
人类的起源是可争论的。
对吧?
3
changye
Jun '10
Thankfully, his finger doesn't point your avatar yet, hehe. Incidentally, you used a few “平等” in your Chinese comments here, but I'm afraid I don't understand well what you want to say using the word. Would you please elaborate it a little more?
3
Tal
Jun '10
呵呵,do you mean my finger is pointing to a star, and therefore mankind came from the stars? It's true!
But as for 北京猿人 meaning there's a separate origin for 东方人 from westerners, that's just not true! Analysis of DNA from humans all over the world reveal that all the people now alive are descendants of those who left Africa roughly 100,000 years ago.
3
changye
Jun '10
Oh, I didn't notice the star in tal's avatar.
3
xiaophil
Jun '10
谢谢你的鼓励!
我觉得应该这样写:
今天我们要来思考一个问题,随着达尔文的物种起源,在世界上出现一件好多人无法同意的事情——人是从哪儿来的?有的人说是神创造了人;有的人说人是一个进化的产物;你的答案是什么呢?快来告诉我们吧!
或者:
今天我们要来思考一个问题,一个连聪明的科学家们、哲学家们与神学家们都无法同意的问题——人是从哪儿来的?有的人说人是一个进化的产物;有的人说是神创造了人;你的答案是什么呢?快来告诉我们吧!
我觉得第二段落最好。
3
aylish
Jun '10
很高兴看到关于达尔文的课。他的房子距我的才有几里,我天天骑自行车过。
真钦佩他!
3
aylish
Jun '10
Not so balanced for us Pangu worshippers...
3
alexyzye
Jun '10
Just because Chinese people are descendants of the latest waves of humans from Africa does not preclude the possibility that they "mixed" with Homo Erectus that arrived earlier. This would explain distinctive Chinese facial characteristics as well as skulls found in Jinnuishan and Dali from 200,000 years ago, that combined both H. Erectus and H. Sapiens features. Similarly, modern Europeans have some Neanderthal genes in them (recently confirmed).
3
Tal
Jun '10
Hi alexyzye
The link I posted states "little or no interbreeding of Homo erectus and Homo sapiens occurred after the migration". Personally, I think it's extremely speculative to attribute Chinese facial characteristics to interbreeding with Homo Erectus. As for skulls being similar, that's a subjective thing in my view; one 'expert' will say they are similar, another will disagree.
3
Tal
Jun '10
干得好,xiaophil! CPod 应该雇佣你呀!我更喜欢你第一段,然而大概因为我的中文阅读不怎么样!
对了,我觉得还有一个问题。好像那么多人不可以接受进化论,可是为什么?可能是因为人生非常短,你说呢?
3
xiaophil
Jun '10
有可能有好多原因,但是我觉得最重要的两个是:
1。死了以后,好多人想去天堂,可是进化论跟主要的宗教教导的人类的起源互相矛盾。因此,有的人认为最好是支持宗教,支持进化论真的没用。可是我应该说好多宗教派能接受进化论,我记得以前罗马教皇以前说进化论有道理。
2。不小人简直不能接受人类和猴子有关系,这样的人狠顽固,一点也没有逻辑。
3
xiaophil
Jun '10
CPod
By the way, I really do think the lesson introduction above should be changed. Call me picky, but it is misleading, and could even be misconstrued as being biased against scientific interpretations of the origin of humankind (although I'm sure that isn't your intention).
3
catherinem
Jun '10
I think the intro simply refers to the fact that scientists still haven't come to a consensus on where exactly humans come from. The out of africa theory has certainly been the preferred one for the past 20 years or so, but there are still lots of gaps in our knowledge of the path from chimp to homo sapien! That being said, I don't think it was the author of the introduction's intention to cast doubt on the theory of evolution.
3
Tal
Jun '10
I've noticed that people who find the fact of evolution unpalatable like to say things like 'not all scientists agree with Darwin's theory' or 'there is no consensus re. evolution even among scientists'. This untruth has become a kind of touchstone it seems, but mainly I think it shows that the people who use this line don't understand the way science works, let alone evolution.
Your own choice of words here is inexact and misleading catherine. There is no path from 'chimp to homo sapien'. Long ago there were ape-like creatures which were the ancestors of both chimps and us however.
3
xiaophil
Jun '10
No offense Catherine, if you take other parts of the intro into account (i.e later on we are given two straightforward theories: humans come from god or apes), and take note that 一个连聪明的科学家们都无法解决的问题 is written in simple terms, the message does not seem to mean "although scientist are generally in agreement that evolution is the origin of humankind, they still haven't come to a total conclusion." No, it seems to simply say, "Scientist don't know." I know I'm being a bit picky, but it kind of irks me when science is misrepresented. My point is, might as well make it clear.
3
JasonSch
Jun '10
It should be noted that the Chinese teacher who wrote this does in fact believe in evolution. Any perceived bias is simply the result of the author attempting to be sensitive to the fact that some users may not chose to subscribe to the idea.
I wouldn't read so much into the wording of Catherine's comment above. It's clearly a common euphemism/expression, not a scientific analysis.
3
xiaophil
Jun '10
Again, I'm not saying that anything was intentional. I'm just commenting on how it appears. I gave two examples above (now in the hidden portion) that I think would be suitable for all poddies. I think sensitivity goes both ways, right?
3
Tal
Jun '10
Oh, I didn't mean that I thought catherine was deliberately trying to be misleading. I don't mean any offence here. I agree with phil though that clarity and a commitment to a true representation of science is important.
3
jameck
Jun '10
在中国中学生的生物课本上,生物的进化过程是由原始生命(单细胞动物之前)经过n年进化来的,不过语文课本里也有各种想女娲造人这样的美妙故事。
3
jameck
Jun '10
在中国,中学生物可课本和考试都支持进化论,不过相信与否,随你便,因为不同的人都有不同的宗教信仰。
3
infophreak
Jun '10
对,不同人有不同的宗教信仰,但进化论并不是一种宗教或信仰。
3
jameck
Jun '10
可是它与一些宗教相冲突。对了,待会儿我要考试(语文),很没底啊...
3
infophreak
Jun '10
有冲突,但进化论有证据。信不信无关。信什么就信。我尊敬人的信仰权利,但尊敬他们所信仰是另一回事。
3
xiaophil
Jun '10
This picture reminds me of one of my all-time favorite bands, Devo.
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_does_the_name_Devo_mean
3
bababardwan
Jun '10
women shibushi ren? women shi 低斡
3
xiaophil
Jun '10
HAHA! I totally get it. I think I would write:
women nandao bushi ren? women shi 低斡.
3
tanglang
Jun '10
in order to understand my 平等-argument in this context, it might help to understand the notorious history of the country where I was born. Hitler used Darwinism to explain why he thinks some human races are above others. He considered Jews as inferior and therefore saw himself justified to kill 6 million innocent people. The majority of the germans obviously subscribed to this and didn't go against him.
It would be only logical if the 古猿 story would be true that we have different semi-human ancestors. But tal pointed (with his beautiful finger) to the fact that all humankind has the same ancestors (as our genes reveal). This matches perfectly with the Bibles Genesis-record of common ancestors made by an intelligent creator. Common ancestors, 人家都平等 is the simple reasoning we find in the Bible.
3
bababardwan
Jun '10
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pangu
3
aylish
Jun '10
有一些,但没有很多。其实他的故居在一个很小的村庄里,我住在旁边的村庄。
Jenny, 你来访问吧,我陪你去!
3
Tal
Jun '10
Thanks for the compliment tanglang!
On the subject of evolution and religion, I am not myself a believer in any deity, but I don't necessarily see any conflict between religion and evolution. I don't really understand why many religious people should feel so threatened, frightened or demeaned by the facts of human evolution. If there is a creator, then evolution could be seen as simply how he/she/it gets things done, right?
Re. Hitler and others who have misused Darwin's ideas, it seems to me that many people do not understand what Darwin really meant by "survival of the fittest" (设置生存). He didn't mean survival of the strongest, or the most ruthless or cruel. He meant survival of the 'best adapted', survival of those creatures most in harmony with their environment.
I agree wholeheartedly that it is so important (and actually wonderful) that we understand the kinship, not just of all humanity, but of all life on Earth. This is a thing 进化论 reveals to us. Darwin's great book concludes, in grand and beautiful style:
"There is grandeur in this view of life, with its several powers, having been originally breathed into a few forms or into one; and that, whilst this planet has gone cycling on according to the fixed law of gravity, from so simple a beginning endless forms most beautiful and most wonderful have been, and are being, evolved."
3
alexyzye
Jun '10
I thought evolution is an observed phenomenon (even before Darwin) and what Darwin gave us was the Theory of Natural Selection to explain evolution. To say one does not believe in evolution is akin to saying one does not believe in observed facts. Makes no sense.
3
xiaophil
Jun '10
我同意你的想法,可是有些基督原教旨主义者认为魔王为了使人糊涂把恐龙的骨头埋在地下了。
3
tanglang
Jun '10
Great input, tal_!
Darwin really has been misunderstood by Hitler. He is also misunderstood by people ourdays who claim that they do not believe in God but rather in Darwin. Interestingly, the chinese version of "The Origin of Species" censored Darwin himself by explaining in an extra comment in the text that he didn't mean God who put life on earth, but he meant "nature", although Darwin used "creator" in this context.
Darwins great scientific achivement was that he proofed that life can change. But until now there is no proof that life can change to the extend of having cats evolved into dogs or apes evolved into man. I can accept these as hyphoteses, but scientific facts are something different. 1+1=2, was a fact with the ancient greeks and will be a fact for all times.
3
infophreak
Jun '10
People never say that they "Believe in Darwin", it's not about believe in this case, rather about evidence. And don't confuse mathematics with science, in mathematics, yes things are proven, but in science empiricism is used, and mathematics is used as a tool. Things are not "proven" in science. We eliminate what we can find to not be true, via experimentation. And experimentation depends on our technology, the more we advance in technology, the better we can experiment.
3
henning
Jun '10
tanglang,
ever heard of Lenski's E. coli long-term evolution experiment?
That one comes pretty close!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E._coli_long-term_evolution_experiment
3
aylish
Jun '10
我记得学习A-level生物学的时候我们得学上帝创造人的故事!这不是坏事吗? 老师很不高兴但他被政府管手管脚的。
我的学校也叫‘达尔文学校’!
3
aylish
Jun '10
这儿有人读过 “读故事学汉语‘ 吗?是一本很好的书。第一个故事就是‘盘古和女娲’。
3
tanglang
Jun '10
Thanks for the link Henning! I read it with interest, but I ask myself it comes close to what? To the fact that life can change by mutations, and some mutations can even benefit the bacteria? If this is considered a great proof that humans evolved from bacterias, there is much more faith needed to believe in evolution-theory than in God.
3
infophreak
Jun '10
You obviously don't understand the algorithmic-like process of evolution. You are along the route of saying that it's statistically improbable, when the process is a lot more deterministic than you think. Hengning's example wasn't to "show" that humans evolved directly from bacteria, but rather a sample of evolution in a small environment over a small period of time. If you find it hard to imagine how single-celled organisms (such as algae) can evolve to multicelled organisms (fungi for example) over a million years, then don't waste your time trying to understand more advanced multicellular organisms, like humans.
3
changye
Jun '10
宇宙那么神秘,人体这么精巧,我有时不禁相信上帝创造世界的故事。所谓起源问题常有争议,这样才有趣,也才有科学发展。
3
tgif
Jun '10
Thankfully, we live in a time period where we can clearly differentiate between a religious belief and a scientific belief. BTW, I know this is very common among nonscientists, David makes a common mistake thinking Darwin addressed the origins of life. Contrary to his statement that we will be debating the origins of life for a long time, this research is making huge headway and I confidently predict we will have at least several strong tested theories about how life arose without resorting to fables, idle speculation or seeding from the stars.
I find it also fascinating how many religions (Islam, Greek Prometheus) believe man was fashioned from mud/clay and had life blown in.
3
changye
Jun '10
HI tgif
Some earliest Japanese gods, a kind of living gods, are said to have been created from oily materials floating on the water, which seems to be very "scientific", hehe.
3
tanglang
Jun '10
《我腑脏的深处是你造的; 我在母亲腹中, 你就一直覆庇我。 我要赞颂你, 因为我的受造奇妙可畏。 你的作为奇妙, 我是清楚知道的。 我在暗中受造, 在地的最深处被编织成形; 当时我的骨骼 在你眼前并不隐蔽。 我还是胚胎的时候, 你的眼睛就看见我了。 我身上未有一处成形, 我百体受造的日子 都已经记在你的册上了》(以色列国王大卫, 公元前1000年左右, 圣经,诗篇 139:13-16).
特别值得注意就是他怎么形容基因运作 ,《都已经记在你的册上》.
3
henning
Jun '10
tanglang,
the interesting part of the experiment is that the bacteria evolved beyond their initial set of capabilities - to the point where you consider them to be a different species: One population developed a completely new feature - they became able to make use of new sources of energy. Think of man developing gills or being able to digest oil...
Actually I agree that man did not evolve from apes.
Because we still are apes. Apart from the cognitive capabilities and of course language not much evolution out of the "ape state" has happened. Just look at our bodily features, our set of behavioural patterns, our clan based social structure (which tragically involves betrayal and war), even our value system (altruism, caring for the handicaped) - go to the chimpanzees and you find it all. I suscpect that even our tendency to superstition / religion is nothing but a by-product of our ape heritage.
3
ouxiansheng
Jun '10
我觉得这种课很有用,因为让欣赏怎么使用汉语来解释在学校已经学会的事情。下门有我听不清楚的地方:0:14 Connie,你说了看4:25 盘古手震的天,然后脚踏着地地,然后以使劲把那个天和地给分开来了4:43再合起来呢,他就站在了这个中间5:05 世界呢万物5:12喊叫声变成了雷5:13呼吸声变成了风5:37 少了yang东西5:40 有一天她走来chitangbian的时候6:09 照他们的鼻孔里吹气8:35 你必须要去那根辫子去datang8:45 振作精神10:20 从地球诞生12:18 按照条例12:32 引进了很多的项目12:37 年度最佳员工15:59 就是好像是借喻他们在进化过程当中16:13外星造人谢谢!
3
tanglang
Jun '10
We are all apes and life comes from outer space. I am happy that true scientists give us so much enlightement here on chinesepod!
3
henning
Jun '10
tanglang,
a scientist would first ask: How do you define an ape? How a human? Then proceed from there.
And of course apply Occam's razor (奥卡姆剃刀) to come to the conclusion that the bible (and all other religious texts with it) are best left in the garbage can of history.
3
Tal
Jun '10
Actually though the Bible does have some good bits in it if you can appreciate great poetry and stories. (It can also tell us a lot about the mindset of Bronze Age tent dwellers.) It's spoiled by religious people, especially those who insist on taking it as literally true.
Life's Raw Materials May Have Come From The Stars
3
changye
Jun '10
HI henning,
I think both are virtually saying the same thing.
3
tanglang
Jun '10
希望你不会太失望。 黑暗中世纪的天主教已经试试把圣经扔掉,烧掉那些把圣经翻译成别语言的人, 没有成功。20世纪的共产党也试过, 都失败了。
据估计圣经(全书或部分内容)的印刷数量已超过47亿本。跟分发量第二的《毛主席语录》相比,圣经的分发量超过了5倍以上。
最近某一年,圣经全书或部分内容,分发量也超过5000万本。“圣经是该年最畅销的书,也是每年最畅销的书。”——《纽约客》杂志。
圣经全书或部分内容已翻译成2400多种语言。全球超过百分之90的人,都可以看到自己母语的圣经全书或其部分内容的译本。
3
rain_chen
Jun '10
想交外国友人 我是个大学生 我的MSN是想交朋友的可以加我 哦 当然 我会汉语
I want to make friends with foreign friends ,I am a college student ,This is my MSN a420589751@msn.cn , OH! of course , I can Chinese
3
bababardwan
Jun '10
ah yes, the rhetorical 难道...definitely gets much more on the vibe ..well done mate. I don't think I've ever gotten to a confident stage of using 难道 properly myself,but this was the perfect time I guess. I'm glad you liked my little joke,hehe and accepted 低斡
3
isthatme
Jun '10
久而久之 science marches on and disproves superstition after superstition. While religion remains static and only changes it's (their) arguments to try and keep up with science. There is a reason The Enlightenment is called The Enlightenment.
3
henning
Jun '10
ishatme,
"try to keep up with science": this is what Kuhn called "ad-hoc moves" (or exhaustion). The better explanation is replacing the older one not by being more convincing but by a new generation...it needs patience.
3
connie
Jun '10
0:14 Connie,你说说看
4:25 盘古手撑着天,然后脚踏着地,然后一使劲把那个天和地给分开来了
4:43再合起来呢,他就站在了这个中间
5:05 世间的万物
5:12喊叫声变成了雷
5:13呼吸声变成了风
5:37 少了一样东西(这里的"样"是个量词。)
5:40 有一天她坐在池塘边的时候
6:09 朝他们的鼻孔里吹气
8:35 你必须要去拿根鞭子去打他
8:45 振作精神
10:20 从地球诞生
12:18 按照条理来写就能写出一篇很好的文章
12:32 引进了很多的项目
12:37 年度最佳员工
15:59 也就好像是介于他们在进化的过程当中
16:13 外星造人
3
henning
Jun '10
changye,
actually not. "Responsibility" incurs the option of enforcing positive or negative sanctions. But here 责任 is more like a function. You wouldn't punish the leg if it doesn't keep the body in the air.
3
changye
Jun '10
HI henning
"Take over the task of" can be translated as “承担任务”. It seems to me that both expressions, “承担责任” and “承担任务”, are merely a kind of metaphor, a figure of speech, or personification. You can "punish" the leg by slapping it, hehe.
3
malacca
Jun '10
我 不 知道 古猴 能 不 能 用 工 具,可 是 现 在 的 猴 子 一 定 知 道 了.还 有 别 的 动 物.比 如 海 豹 在 它的 肚子 上 能 用 石 头 把坚果砸开.比 如乌鸦 知道 找 到 工具得到食品.
3
dahouxiaohou
Jun '10
嘿!老师们好!
虽然我跟着CPOD学习很长时间了,我是刚开始听高级课程的课。
这是我第一次听没有john和jenny的课,我就要给你们说你们讲得很不错!
谢谢! (好了,马屁精说好了 ;-))
3
calicartel
Jun '10
The podcasters waste too much time on the Pangu stuff. I find creation mythologies boring to the extreme. To boot, I don't find them a good way to learn vocab because they tell such shaggy-dog stories that I find myself unable to supply the missing words from general knowledge.
All the same, "scholarly" lessons are on the whole a good way to build up vocab. What about a lesson about the (Chinese) space programme? We could learn such words as "Appollo mission" + the name of the planets.
3
mark
Jun '10
There is a lesson that names the planets. Its particular distraction is a rather lame guy is trying to get a young woman to go look at the stars with him. I think if you did a search of the lesson content for 水星, you would probably find it.
BTW, I don't agree with your comments about creation myths. I know how to talk about that kind of thing in English, so it seems like fair game for lesson content to me. Also, the creation myth in this lesson was one I didn't know of before. So, I figured I picked up some cultural knowledge, along with the anthropology.
3
tingyun
Jun '10
It was an upper intermediate lesson, called Stargazing
Its not a terribly good way to learn the names of the planets, as it doesn't seem to do much with them (beyond naming them at various times). In the dialogue, you could switch around where some of the planets are named and not destroy its coherency (ie saturn, mars, jupiter, mercury, etc). Thus, listening to the dialogue doesn't really help you learn the names of the planets (except to the extent you are conciously saying "mars, mars" to yourself as the dialogue comes 火星). I think to be effective in teaching new vocab, its meaning has to be part of its use in the dialogue. You'll probably more easily learn the word for Mars from one of the dialogues that have someone saying "你是不是火星人?连这点常识都不知道。 " or something to that effect.
I remember there being a media lesson on the controversy over pluto being a planet - now, that would be a good way to get 冥王星 imprinted in your memory.
3
daisy1987
Jul '10
Hi,xiaophil
别介意,这句话如果这么说会不会更好:今天我们来讨论一个问题,这个问题引起过众多学家的争议,直到今天这个争议也还存在,这个问题就是——人是从哪儿来的?科学家说人是一个进化的产物;神学家说是上帝创造了人;那么你的看法是什么呢?快来告诉我们吧!
我觉得答案换成看法,思考换成讨论也许会更好一点,呵呵
3
xiaophil
Jul '10
Daisy
你放心,我没介意,而且我很感激你的修改!我会在笔记本写下你的建议!
其实,我觉得接下来更好点:
今天我们来讨论一个问题,这个问题引起过众多学家的争议,直到今天这个争议也还存在,这个问题就是——人是从哪儿来的?好多科学家说人是一个进化的产物;好多神学家说是上帝创造了人;那么你的看法是什么呢?快来告诉我们吧!
有的神学家毕竟相信进化理论,有的科学家觉得人是上帝造的。
关于“我觉得答案换成看法,思考换成讨论也许会更好一点”,我也怎么觉得。
3
daisy1987
Jul '10
嗯,你说的对,不是每个科学家都认同进化论。那么我稍微改动一下,许多科学家认为人是一个进化的产物而许多神学家则认为是上帝创造了人。在表达观点的时候可以用认为和觉得,不过觉得的意思没有认为强烈,它更多表达的是人的一种感觉,而认为则有表达看法的意思。在表达两个不同观点的时候中间可以加个“而”字~
xiaophil,我忽然觉得把:今天我们来讨论一个问题,把“问题”可以改成“话题”,嗯这样看就觉得我改的话没那么别扭了
嗯,我在想把:那么你的看法,换成。。那么你的观点,会不会更好呢?不过“看法”和“观点”这两个词我一直不太清楚他们的区别,这个问题困惑我很久了。
指出你的一个小错误,最后一句,我也这(zhe)么觉得,你写成平舌的怎(zen)了
xiaophil你觉得人是进化来的还是上帝创造的呢?中国有句俗话说,女人是水做的,那么我更愿意相信女人是水进化来的哈哈
3
xiaophil
Jul '10
Daisy
因为我的注意力现在有点分散,所以打印了你的修改和说明。我今晚坐地铁的时候会仔细看。谢谢你的努力,你非常体贴!
3
daisy1987
Jul '10
Aha~xiaophil,it's my pleasure.学好一门外语的目的是收获快乐,哈哈
3
Tal
Jul '10
"I suscpect [sic] that even our tendency to superstition / religion is nothing but a by-product of our ape heritage."
This is a bit late actually, but your words above keep coming back to me. It was the one point in that post I couldn't quite buy. Care to expand on it? Is it possible to observe even rudimentary forms of superstition/religion amongst our ape cousins?
3
xiaophil
Jul '10
Without an explanation, I don't buy it either. In my opinion, religion is a tool humans use to explain why their environment is the way it is, to provide a basis for morality and to give hope that there will be an afterlife. I could be wrong, but I don't think these would be a primary concern of our simian-esque ancestors. Then again, in theory the evolution of man from ape-like creatures must have been a slow process. Some of these concerns might have been present in "pre-humans". But regardless of who started it, I am willing to bet humans took it to the prominent level it has been in for as far back in history as scientist can see.
3
Tal
Jul '10
Sadly it seems that henning is too busy to comment on this issue further, so I was recalling a TV show I saw once about wild chimpanzees. A famous researcher (can't recall who) remotely filmed a male chimp visiting a beautiful isolated waterfall. The behaviour was interesting. Apparently the animal seemed deeply moved by the rushing water and the thunderous sound, leaping and cavorting, occasionally uttering wild whoops of joy. And yet would often pause and stare at the water in silence, sometimes making gestures to absent friends. Perhaps one facet of the origin of man's 'spiritual' feeling can be seen here, in some kind of awe at the natural world that boils over into ecstasy and a sense of the numinous .
3
calicartel
Jul '10
Yeah, I was thinking about something (which in CP will has to be a dialogue, apparently) with a scientific approach, along the lines of SBTG. With concepts of distance, size an temperature. I find quantitative notions hard to learn in Chinese.
3
yingshilangbu
Nov '10
The thing is that every chinese student learns these stories in middle school, and to an extent hold these creation myths dear to them on account of them being part of the early stages of the development of the national chinese character. As such pangu will occasionally come up in conversation. The creation myths mentions are a part of the most basic general knowledge of the chines people. So I think it is a very useful lesson for people who are intersted in China.
3
yingshilangbu
Nov '10
我觉得上帝创造了人类. 这就意味着'进化论'的存在. 所以即使说人类是由古猿进化而来的,他们还是有创造者.
3
luo2mo4zi
May '11
Darwin's theory is so boring and lacks many things which Vladamir Vernadsky laid out. It would be awesome if some podcast could cover Vernadsky's Biosphere (bookhttp://www.amazon.com/Biosphere-Complete-Annotated-Vladimir-Vernadsky/dp/038798268X), and other writings of his which cover evolution.
A couple things which should be stated about evolution; one Darwin isn't the only one who has ideas regarding evolution. Two, the main problem with Darwin's concept of evolution is that it actually lacks the entire context of the development of the Biosphere.
No organism in the Universe is an isolated thing in and of itself, every organism is a part of the environment. The environment is constantly going through a series of transformations that are irreversible. No one state of the Biosphere is ever the same. I don't doubt that our bodies are very much like apes, but I don't think one can neglect to context in which the ape came out of. In other words more important than any individual organism is the evolution of the Biosphere itself.
I find that the most interesting thing Vernadsky states in his Biosphere book is the fact that the evolution is very much a cosmic phenomenon because of the earth's relationship to the sun. In fact plants photosynthesize which makes cosmic rays a vital part of our Biosphere (In this case those of the UV range).
There is some evidence to show that organisms evolve certain traits simultaneously in certain Geological periods without needing to have sex with each other. In other words they evolve almost at the same time. Nothing in Darwin's theories could account for this, but I do think that there may be some type of cosmic causality for this.
Oh and as for religion, some people think that mind came after the body developed certain traits. I think that it is the other way around, the mind existed in the Universe first, which then necessitated evolution to occur the way in which it did. That's my religion!
3
floalvarez
Jan '13
一些词汇:
劈 pī to divide; to split; to break off
使劲 shǐ jìn exert all of one's strength; to use or apply great force
物种 wù zhǒng [Biology] species
演化 yǎn huà evolution
混沌 hùn dùn primal chaos; formless mass before creation in Chinese mythology; muddled
预示 yù shì forebode; (vt) foreshadow; to augur
诗句 shī jù verse
烦困 fán kùn tired and listless
灭亡 miè wáng be destroyed; become extinct
使得 shǐ de feasible; to cause
条理 tiáo lǐ arrangement; orderliness; method; system
介于 jiè yú [Mathematics] to lie in between
周口店 zhōu kǒu diàn Zhoukoudian in Fanshan district, Beijing
萎靡不振 wěi mí bù zhèn to be low in spirits; dejected and apathetic
生物学家 shēng wù xué xué biologist
物种起源 wù zhǒng qǐ yuán Charles Darwin's Origin of Species
山顶洞人 shān dǐng dòng rén upper caveman
3
floalvarez
Jan '13
春晓
唐·孟浩然
春眠不觉晓
处处闻啼鸟。
夜来风雨声
花落知多少。
3
floalvarez
Jan '13
我的问题在引号里面:
@7.08“就是说”。
@8.37“然后砰的一下”跳起来了。
@11.19我们是“以”上面或下面的。
@11.42“就寻找的意思”。
@16.35很多“种”我们不知道。
3
lujiaojie
Jan '13
@7.08 就说:
@8.37“然后砰的一下”跳起来了。对!
@11.19我们是(“以”没有”以“,这里是主持人多说了,多发了一个音)上面或下面的。
@11.42“就是寻找的意思”。对!
@16.35很多“种”我们不知道的。对!
3
floalvarez
Jan '13
徐州的“就说”和“就是说”我很难搞清楚!
查了字典以后,我得知“就是说”的英文翻译是:in other words; that is。 请问“就说”的英文是什么?
谢谢!
3
lujiaojie
Jan '13
“就说” 意思是:just say......
比如,我们想让他解梦的时候,就说:哎,我做了个什么什么梦,表示什么呢?
3
jloo
Jul '13
1)在意 在乎 都有什么区别?
2)‘。。是由原始生命经过n年进化来的’。 由。。。后面可以省略而? 这个结构是不是应该有而在后面? ’是由原始生命经过n年而进化来的’
3) 干扰 打扰 骚扰 干涉 都有什么区别?用哪个最恰当?
3
lujiaojie
Jul '13
1)在意 在乎 都有什么区别? 没什么区别。
2)‘。。是由原始生命经过n年进化来的’。 由。。。后面可以省略而? 这个结构是不是应该有而在后面? ’是由原始生命经过n年而进化来的’
可以加“而”,也可以省略。
3) 干扰 打扰 骚扰 干涉 都有什么区别?用哪个最恰当?
”干扰“和”打扰“ 都可以用于”别人忙的时候,去影响他“:比如:他在工作,不要打扰/干扰他。打扰更常用。
”干扰“常用于”信号被干扰“。比如:由于台风,手机信号受到了干扰,不太稳定。
骚扰:常用于”性骚扰“,”骚扰电话“,”敌人骚扰边境“等等, 是贬义的。
干涉:指管别人的事。比如:有些父母总喜欢干涉孩子的事情。这是我的事情,你们不要干涉你。
3
589612630
Dec '24
The so-called biological evolution is anti genetics.
No way, a creature develops to another species.
3
589612630
Dec '24
The so-called biological evolution is anti genetics.
No way, a creature develops to another species.
3
589612630
Dec '24
The so-called biological evolution is anti genetics.
No way, a creature develops to another species.
3
589612630
Dec '24
The so-called biological evolution is anti genetics.
No way, a creature develops to another species.
3